This thread is for discussions of Using Encryption in .NET.

Hi,

Great article,

Just one question though, how do you transmit your IV's? I mean, decryction usually happens at another computer and for encryption and decryption you suggest to use the iv?

regards,

Wilfred Kuijpers
dbhost

You transmit the IV in the clear (unencrypted).  Just add the IV to your transmitted message so the receiving computer can decrypt the message.  There's no need to encrypt the IV because it is used simply to randomize the cipher text to prevent repetition.

--
Steve Johnson

Wouldn't this mean that for eavesdroppers using the same random generator (which can not be that big a problem) and the transmitted seed it is possible to retrieve the 'un-randomized' (if thats a word) still encrypted content?

Wilfred Kuijpers
dbHost

Using CBC as an example, encryption proceeds as follows:
1 - XOR Plain Text Block #1 with IV
2 - Encrypt the block resulting from step 1 with the key
3 - The Cipher Text block resulting from step 3 is used as Cipher Text block #1
4 - XOR Plain Text block #2 with Cipher Text block #1
5 - Encrypt the block resulting from step 4 with the key
6 - The Cipher Text block resulting from step 5 is used as Cipher Text block #2
7 - etc, etc...

There's no way to reverse this process without the key.  The IV is not being used to seed a PRNG; it's simply used as random data, with which to mix the first block of plain text on encryption and to retrieve the initial plain text block on decryption.  As you can see, there is no intermediate "non-randomized" state that can be determined using the cipher text and the IV.

--
Steve Johnson

Regarding my comment that "there is "no way" to reverse this process without the key."

I want to be clear that I mean that there is no *trivial* way to do this.  What I'm trying to say is that the process is as secure as the key and the underlying cipher.

There is, of course, no such thing as "no way" in cryptography.  We just try to use the best technology we can to make it as difficult and expensive as possible for an attacker to break the system.

--
Steve Johnson

First of all, I'd like to say that this was a fantastic article.  I was struggling through the MSDN info and other online articles and your article finally made everything clear.

I want to use this technique to encrypt credit card data before I store it in SQL Server.  I take the ASCII credit card number, convert it to an array of bytes using the ASCII encoder and then encrypt the bytes.  The trouble is that the bytes are now out of the ASCII range (0 to 127), so I can't convert the bytes back to an ASCII string to store in a VarChar column of a SQL Server table.

It seems like a solution is to convert the encrypted bytes to a unicode string using the unicode encoder and store that value in a NVarChar column.  The only problem with this is that I usually avoid unicode SQL Server columns.  Is this the only solution or do you have any other ideas?

Hi,

I'm attempting to do the same thing. I've gone down the route of converting the cipher's byte array to a Hex string using the following: -

   BitConverter.ToString(bytEncryptedMessage);

This creates a hyphon delimitted string (e.g. 0A-10-FA etc...) which can be stored in the database.


When I want to decrypt I'm first calling the following function: -

// Assumes the hex string values are "-" delimitted. e.g. 0A-FA-BD
       public byte[] HexStringToBytes(string sHexString)
       {
           string[]        sStringArray;
           byte[]            bytByteArray;
           int                iCount = 0;

           sStringArray = sHexString.Split('-');
           bytByteArray = new byte[sStringArray.Length];
   
           foreach (string sHexValue in sStringArray)
           {
               bytByteArray[iCount] = byte.Parse(sHexValue, NumberStyles.HexNumber);
               iCount ++;
           }

           return bytByteArray;
       }

which re-creates the byte array.



I thought I'd cracked it, but something really weird is happening!! When decrypted - the first 32 characters are garbage - everything after is fine!!!

I'm guessing this is something to do with the padding, but not sure.

Hope this points you in the right direction and would also really appreciate any assistance with the problem I'm having!

Hi all,

Excellent article - made a lot of sense.

I've created a little test app which converts the byte arrays to hex strings (for storing in DB) - and then does the reverse. This all seems to work, but for some strange reason the first 32 characters of the decrypted string are garbled (everything after this point is fine!!).

I'm guessing it's something to do with padding, but not sure - maybe I'm missing something really obvious!

Any help would be hugely appreciated. I've posted the code from my test form below (hope you're okay about this and hope it benefits others)..

cheers.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
using System;
using System.Drawing;
using System.Collections;
using System.ComponentModel;
using System.Windows.Forms;
using System.Data;

using System.Security.Cryptography;
using System.Text;
using System.IO;
using System.Globalization;        // for NumberStyles

namespace EncryptionTool
{
   /// <summary>
   /// Summary description for Form1.
   /// </summary>
   public class Form1 : System.Windows.Forms.Form
   {
       private System.Windows.Forms.TextBox txtToEncrypt;
       private System.Windows.Forms.Label label1;
       private System.Windows.Forms.Button btnDecrypt;
       private System.Windows.Forms.Label label2;
       private System.Windows.Forms.TextBox txtKey;
       private System.Windows.Forms.Label label3;
       private System.Windows.Forms.Button btnEncrypt;
       private System.Windows.Forms.TextBox txtEncrypted;
       private System.Windows.Forms.TextBox txtDecrypted;
       private System.Windows.Forms.Label label4;
       /// <summary>
       /// Required designer variable.
       /// </summary>
       private System.ComponentModel.Container components = null;

       public Form1()
       {
           //
           // Required for Windows Form Designer support
           //
           InitializeComponent();

           //
           // TODO: Add any constructor code after InitializeComponent call
           //
       }

       /// <summary>
       /// Clean up any resources being used.
       /// </summary>
       protected override void Dispose( bool disposing )
       {
           if( disposing )
           {
               if (components != null)
               {
                   components.Dispose();
               }
           }
           base.Dispose( disposing );
       }

       #region Windows Form Designer generated code
       /// <summary>
       /// Required method for Designer support - do not modify
       /// the contents of this method with the code editor.
       /// </summary>
       private void InitializeComponent()
       {
           this.txtToEncrypt = new System.Windows.Forms.TextBox();
           this.label1 = new System.Windows.Forms.Label();
           this.txtEncrypted = new System.Windows.Forms.TextBox();
           this.btnDecrypt = new System.Windows.Forms.Button();
           this.label2 = new System.Windows.Forms.Label();
           this.txtKey = new System.Windows.Forms.TextBox();
           this.label3 = new System.Windows.Forms.Label();
           this.btnEncrypt = new System.Windows.Forms.Button();
           this.txtDecrypted = new System.Windows.Forms.TextBox();
           this.label4 = new System.Windows.Forms.Label();
           this.SuspendLayout();
           //
           // txtToEncrypt
           //
           this.txtToEncrypt.Location = new System.Drawing.Point(8, 72);
           this.txtToEncrypt.Multiline = true;
           this.txtToEncrypt.Name = "txtToEncrypt";
           this.txtToEncrypt.Size = new System.Drawing.Size(448, 80);
           this.txtToEncrypt.TabIndex = 1;
           this.txtToEncrypt.Text = "";
           //
           // label1
           //
           this.label1.Location = new System.Drawing.Point(8, 56);
           this.label1.Name = "label1";
           this.label1.TabIndex = 2;
           this.label1.Text = "Text to encrypt";
           //
           // txtEncrypted
           //
           this.txtEncrypted.Location = new System.Drawing.Point(8, 176);
           this.txtEncrypted.Multiline = true;
           this.txtEncrypted.Name = "txtEncrypted";
           this.txtEncrypted.Size = new System.Drawing.Size(448, 80);
           this.txtEncrypted.TabIndex = 3;
           this.txtEncrypted.Text = "";
           //
           // btnDecrypt
           //
           this.btnDecrypt.Location = new System.Drawing.Point(464, 184);
           this.btnDecrypt.Name = "btnDecrypt";
           this.btnDecrypt.TabIndex = 4;
           this.btnDecrypt.Text = "&Decrypt";
           this.btnDecrypt.Click += new System.EventHandler(this.btnDecrypt_Click);
           // <

I actually ended up cracking the problem in a different way.  Here's what I do to encode a .NET string:

1.  Turn the string into a byte array using the ASCII encoder.
2.  Run the byte array through the Rijndael encryptor (some bytes cannot now be represented as ASCII chars).
3.  Convert the resulting array of bytes to a Base64 string using Convert.ToBase64String().
4.  The result is an ASCII string which can be strored in regular (non-unicode) database columns.

To decrypt the string I do the reverse:

1.  Convert the string from the database into a byte array using Convert.FromBase64String().
2.  Run the byte array through the Rijndael decryptor.
3.  Convert the resulting array back into a string using the ASCII encoder.

The trick with all of this is that the an 8 bit unicode string can be stored as a 7 bit ASCII string by converting it into a Base64 string.  Base 64 strings use 4 bytes to represent every block of 3 byte unicode characters.  See http://email.about.com/cs/standards/a/base64_encoding.htm for a good intro on base64 strings.  The one thing you have to think about is how long to make your database columns.  Just remember that every block of 3 unencrypted characters results in 4 encrypted characters in the database.

I hope this helps,
Ben Mills

Many thanks Ben - I've got a working solution now!

I think the problem was the fact I'd commented out the initialisation vector code.. I didn't think this was essential.

Anyhow - I've also removed my conversion routines to and from hex as the conversion to base64 strings is a lot more elegant (and the strings generated shorter).

Thanks again.

Problem seems to be fixed now - I'd uncommented the initialisation vector code and it looks like it's mandetory.

Also - replaced the hex encoding with base64 strings (many thanks to Ben Mills on the other thread about storing values in SQL server for pointing me in this direction).

Exactly.  If you don't use the same IV for encryption and decryption, the message can't be properly decoded.

Dear Steve,
I was wondering if you had some insight as to how to best to file encrypting with the rijndael encryption.  Most examples I've found only give info. about how to encrypt messages.  I know you said that the CryptoStream object was beyond your scope, but that's where I'm needing to go with this and I like to use a FileStream instead of a MemoryStream.  I would also like to save the encrypted file in place of the original (which I may just have to rename them differently and then delete the original).  I also know you said that you don't have to write the encryption byte for byte, but how do you do this with a FileStream?  And if you do have to do it byte for byte with a FileStream, then how many bytes do I/should I set it to?  Also, all examples I've seen only demonstrate how to Encrypt a file and not Decrypt it again.  On the decryption, though, I only need to display it and not keep or save it anywhere.  Maybe loading it into a MemoryStream might be better?  Keep in mind that this files could be big (most are images).  Is there any advice you could give or maybe another discussion you have?

Thanks!

Couldn't you also store this in a Varbinary field instead of trying to convert it to a string for a varchar field?